The Collection felt tip liner has always been my holy grail for winged liner but recently I decided that I really needed to switch it up. After searching Boots for ages, I finally chose the Soap and Glory Supercat Eyeliner as I love the brand so why not? Here are my thoughts:
First of all the eyeliner is definitely as great as the Collection one. It is very pigmented and although the tip is pretty thick, it can create thin lines and thicker ones depending on the angle that you use it. As you can see from the photo above I tried to demonstrate this... rather badly I must admit. It is so easy to use which obviously is a plus point! I have not noticed any smudging while I have worn this, even after a tearful spell. I sort of accidentally feel asleep with liner on one night and the next morning when I woke up it was still perfect... something good out of a bad situation I guess. So for £6 this product is pretty great, the packing is cute too! I just cannot choose a favourite between my old love (the Collection liner) and this as although the Collection eyeliner is only £2.99 it does dry out quite quickly which evens out the playing field.
Have you tried this product?